Casing Woes

Today we made up two different styles of door casing.  Both VERY similar...and both very simple.  I really love the look of an old farmhouse and I think either of these would work.

Straight cut even with the sides.

or straight cut that overhangs about 3/4" on each side.

We think we like the top (even with both sides) the most.

To be honest though....we don't really love either of them.  Ugh!

We'll take a few days to look at them both and see what we decide.

Does anyone else find it this hard to make decisions?